
When I first decided I wanted to read 50 books this year, it was mostly with the intention of giving myself a reason to read the classics. Look over my past 47 posts and you'll see how that went. Miserable, epic fail. BUT... here we are, nearing the end of the year, and I have finally read ONE classic:
Washington Square by Henry James. There were so many times in grad school when someone would say something to the effect of, "Oh (blah blah blah) is
sooo Jamesian," and I would sit there, nodding sagely, having no idea what the hell a Jamesian sentence would look or sound like. Well, now I've read James, so there. I thought the plotline of
Washington Square was pretty similar to some of Jane Austen's domestic novels: girl is raised by widower father who is to leave her a fortune; fortune-hunter comes, woos her, and father refuses to allow them to marry; busybody aunt tries to push the two together, and a bit of emotional chaos ensues. This is somewhat similar to the beginning of
Persuasion, one of my favorite Austen novels. However, here's the problem: the heroine of
Persuasion, Anne Elliott, eventually goes from a meek, self-sacrificing daughter to a woman who knows she must put her own happiness before others, and acts accordingly. She is rewarded for both her initial obedience and her eventual self-actualization and backbone. Catherine Sloper, the heroine of
Washington Square , isn't as perceptive, wise, or generous as Anne. She is an obedient daughter, then a consistent lover, and eventually an admired spinster... but while it's easy to be sympathetic towards her, she isn't someone I really admired or connected to. Catherine is a pawn; her father dismisses her as a dull child only there to be amusing to him; her lover, Morris, is only after her fortune; and her live-in aunt, Mrs. Penniman, uses Catherine's complex love affair as an excuse to entertain herself, regardless of the fact that her involvement only causes Catherine more pain. In the end, Catherine is the only one we can still admire, or even respect-- but she is also alone and it just seems so sad and wrong. I'm glad I read
Washington Square, but it certainly didn't leave me smiling.